Coin Problem

some of you may have easily solved the pill weighing problem posed here. If so, you are going to love this problem. It is similar but much more difficult.

from my buddy Tom:

Ok, here’s a tough one (i thought). There are no “aha!” tricks – it requires straightforward deductive-reasoning.

You have 12 coins. one of them is counterfeit. All the good coins weigh the same, while the counterfeit one weights either more or less than a good coin. Your task is to find the counterfeit coin using a balance-scale in 3 weighs. Moreover, you want to say whether the coin weighs more or less than is should and, and this is the real kicker, your weighs must be non-adaptive, that is, your choice of what to put on the balance for your second weigh cannot depend on the outcome of the first weigh and your decision about what to weigh for round 3 cannot depend on what happened either your first or second weigh. For example, you can’t say something like “take coin #1 and coin #2 and weigh them. If they balance, then take coins 3,4,5 and weight them against 6,7,8…if 1 and 2 don’t balance, then weigh #1 vs #12…” you have to say something like:

round #1: do this

round #2: do this

round #3: do this

if the results are left tilt, balanced, and left tilt, respectively, then coin #11 is heavier than it should be.

This problem is solvable…it took me about 1-2 hours of working on it to get it. I think even finding the counterfeit using an adaptive solution is tough. Then non-adaptive constraint makes it quite hard and having to find whether it’s heavier and lighter is cruel and unusual riddling ;-)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>